This page last reviewed May 19, 2014

LCFS Program Review Advisory Panel

Workgroup Meeting Archive

May 19, 2014The first LCFS Advisory Panel meeting will take place on May 19, 2014.  

During this meeting, we will review the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, cover the purpose of the Panel, and have a Panel discussion.

The meeting will be held at the following time and location:

DATE:            Monday, May 19, 2014
TIME:             9:00 am – 4:00 pm
LOCATION:    Sierra Hearing Room, 2nd Floor
                     Cal/EPA Headquarters Building
                     1001 “I” Street
                     Sacramento, California 95814
 

DOCUMENTS

November 17, 2011
A supplemental meeting of the LCFS Advisory Panel will take place on November 17, 2011.

During this meeting, we will discuss the economic analysis as well as meeting the targets. There will also be time allotted for public comments and open discussion.

          The meeting will be held at the following time and location:
          DATE:          Thursday November 17, 2011
          TIME:           12:30 pm - 5:00 pm
          LOCATION:   Sierra Hearing Room 2nd Floor
                              Cal-EPA Headquarters Building
                              1001 "I" Street
                              Sacramento, California 95814

The meeting will also be available via teleconference and webcast.  To call in by telephone, see details below:

You may participate by teleconference by dialing 800-390-3412 (for domestic) or 1-415-228-4974 (for international), give the participant code 2125511, and leader name Mike Waugh.  Please note that if you call internationally, it is a toll call.

If you choose to participate via webcast, please go to the following web address: http://www.calepa.ca.gov/broadcast/?BDO=1, and click on LCFS Advisory Panel Meeting.


October 27, 2011
The fifth and final LCFS Advisory Panel meeting will take place on October 27, 2011. 

During this meeting, we will discuss the draft final version of the regulation review report to the Board. The report includes all of the chapters and topics previously discussed by the Panel in previous meetings. This will be the culminating meeting of the Panel prior to the report to the Board in December. There will also be time allotted for public comments and open discussion.

The meeting will be held at the following time and location:
DATE:            Thursday, October 27, 2011
TIME:             10:00 am – 4:00 pm
LOCATION:    Coastal Hearing Room, 2nd Floor
                     Cal/EPA Headquarters Building
                     1001 “I” Street
                     Sacramento, California 95814

The meeting will also be available via teleconference and webinar.  To call in by telephone, see details below:

You may participate by teleconference by dialing: 800-475-0542 (for domestic) or 1‑210-234-0965 (for international), give the participant code 8782851, and leader name Floyd Vergara.  Please note that if you call internationally, it is a toll call.

If you chose to participate via webinar, please register at https://www1.gotomeeting.com/register/560381737.

If prompted, the webinar ID is: 560-381-737. If you choose to participate via gotowebinar’s audio system and not the teleconference call-in number, you will only be able to listen and see the presentations.  You will not be able to participate using a microphone and must use the call in information provided in the meeting notice if you wish to ask a question verbally.  You may also type your questions to us using a chat box that will be available to you during the webinar.  Staff will be using a computer to answer any questions submitted through the webinar dialogue box.  In the event that the webinar fails, please call in to continue participating.

September 29, 2011The second public meeting to provide and update on the progress of the LCFS Program Review Advisory Panel will take place September 29, 2011.

During this meeting, we will discuss the progress that has been made to date regarding the Panel’s review of the LCFS regulation. This will cover information from July until the last comment period.

The meeting will be held at the following time and location:

DATE:           Thursday, September 29, 2011
TIME:            9:00 am – 11:00 am
LOCATION:    Coastal Hearing Room, 2nd Floor
                     Cal/EPA Headquarters Building
                     1001 “I” Street
                     Sacramento, California 95814

The meeting will also be available via teleconference and webcast.  To call in by telephone, see details below:

You may participate by teleconference by dialing 800-988-9672 (for domestic) or 1-415-228-3902
(for international), give the participant code 6906155, and leader name Mike Waugh.  Please note that if you call internationally, it is a toll call.

If you choose to participate via webcast, please go to the following web address: http://www.calepa.ca.gov/broadcast/?BDO=1, and click on LCFS Advisory Panel Meeting.

August 25 and 26, 2011 The fourth LCFS Advisory Panel meeting will take place on August 25 and 26, 2011.  

During this two-day meeting, we will discuss a myriad of topics that include: harmonization (topic 13); advances in lifecycle assessment (topic 3); supply and availability (topics 4, 5, 6, and 7); meeting the targets (topics 1 and 2); and environmental impacts (topics 9, 10, and 12).  In addition to these topics, staff will provide updates on the economic impacts, HCICO, compliance scenarios, and credit market.  There will also be time allotted for public comments and open discussion.

The meeting will be held at the following time and location:

DATE:            Thursday, August 25, 2011 and Friday, August 26, 2011
TIME:             Thursday: 10:00 am – 4:00 pm
                      Friday: 8:30 am - 12:00 pm
LOCATION:    Coastal Hearing Room, 2nd Floor
                     Cal/EPA Headquarters Building
                     1001 “I” Street
                     Sacramento, California 95814

The meeting will also be available via teleconference and webinar.  To call in by telephone, see details below:

You may participate by teleconference by dialing: 888-917-8040 (for domestic) or 1‑210-234-0002 (for international), give the participant code 1251214, and leader name Mike Waugh.  Please note that if you call internationally, it is a toll call.


If you chose to participate via webinar on Thursday, August 25, 2011 or Friday, August 26, 2011,
please register.

If prompted, the webinar ID is: 
439-531-128 for Thursday and 830-725-160 for Friday. If you choose to participate via gotowebinar’s audio system and not the teleconference call-in number, you will only be able to listen and see the presentations.  You will not be able to participate using a microphone and must use the call in information provided in the meeting notice if you wish to ask a question verbally.  You may also type your questions to us using a chat box that will be available to you during the webinar.  Staff will be using a computer to answer any questions submitted through the webinar dialogue box.  In the event that the webinar fails, please call in to continue participating.

  • Meeting Notice and Agenda (PDF - 229kb)
  • Topic 15 - Harmonization Outline (PDF - 147kb)
  • Report TOC - (PDF - 71kb)
  • Topic 3 - LCA Outline (PDF - 76kb)
  • Topics 1, 2 - Meeting the Targets Outline (PDF - 158kb)
  • Chapter 4 - Technology Assessment Chapter (PDF - 168kb)
  • Chapter 8 - Environmental Chapter (PDF - 399kb)
  • CORRECTED First Quarter LRT Data Summary (PDF - 272kb)
  • Panelist Presentation - Chris Malins - Presentation on harmonization (PDF - 1.76MB)
  • Panelist Presentation - Chris Hessler - Presentation on flexible compliance alternatives (PDF - 119kb)
  • Panelist Presentation - Russell Teall - Biodico Compliance Options (PDF - 85kb)
  • Panelist Report - Environmental Entrepreneurs (E2) Investment Report (PDF - 3.08MB)
  • Panelist Presentation - Bob Epstein - Presentation on the E2 investment report (PDF - 758kb)
  • June/July Meeting Summary (PDF - 221kb)
July 25, 2011
The first public meeting to provide and update on the progress of the LCFS Program Review Advisory Panel will take place July 25, 2011.
During this meeting, we will discuss the purpose of the Panel and progress that has been made to date regarding the Panel’s review of the LCFS regulation.

The meeting will be held at the following time and location:

DATE:           Monday July 25, 2011
TIME:            9:30 am – 11:30 am
LOCATION:    Coastal Hearing Room, 2nd Floor
                     Cal/EPA Headquarters Building
                     1001 “I” Street
                     Sacramento, California 95814

The meeting will also be available via teleconference and webcast.  To call in by telephone, see details below:

You may participate by teleconference by dialing 800-988-9744 (for domestic) or 1-210-234-0113
(for international), give the participant code 4085953, and leader name Floyd Vergara.  Please note that if you call internationally, it is a toll call.

If you choose to participate via webcast, please go to the following web address: http://www.calepa.ca.gov/broadcast/?BDO=1, and click on LCFS Advisory Panel Meeting.

Please note that WSPA had requested an addendum to slide 18 of the presentation, which stated:

"WSPA presented a slide reflecting a simple calculation, using the tool provided by CARB, of the carbon intensities of ethanol necessary to comply with the LCFS requirements for gasoline assuming no change in the 10 percent blend.  [The slide is NOT a representation of whether regulated parties may or may not comply with any regulatory requirement(s). Compliance with regulatory requirements is an individual company/facility process and WSPA does not participate in that process.]"

June 30 and July 1, 2011 The third LCFS Advisory Panel meeting will take place on June 30, 2011 and July 1, 2011.  

During this two day meeting, we will discuss six of the topics suggested by panelists and, required under section 95489 of the LCFS. The items of discussion at this meeting will be: environment (topics 9 &10), economics (topic 12), credit markets (topic 15), technology (topic 4), and High Carbon-Intensity Crude Oil (HCICO) (topic. 14).

The meeting will be held at the following time and location:

DATE:            Thursday, June 30, 2011 and Friday, July 1, 2011
TIME:             Thursday: 10:00 am – 4:00 pm
                      Friday: 9:00 am - 2:30 pm
LOCATION:    Coastal Hearing Room, 2nd Floor
                     Cal/EPA Headquarters Building
                     1001 “I” Street
                     Sacramento, California 95814

The meeting will also be available via teleconference and webinar.  To call in by telephone, see details below:

You may participate by teleconference by dialing 888-469-0646 (for domestic) or 1‑312-470-7382 (for international), give the participant code 52699, and leader name Floyd Vergara.  Please note that if you call internationally, it is a toll call.

If you chose to participate via webinar on Thursday, June 30, 2011 or Friday, July 1, 2011,
please register.

If prompted, the webinar ID is: 307-630-336 for Thursday and 843-849-889 for Friday. If you choose to participate via gotowebinar’s audio system and not the teleconference call-in number, you will only be able to listen and see the presentations.  You will not be able to participate using a microphone and must use the call in information provided in the meeting notice if you wish to ask a question verbally.  You may also type your questions to us using a chat box that will be available to you during the webinar.  Staff will be using a computer to answer any questions submitted through the webinar dialogue box.  In the event that the webinar fails, please call in to continue participating.


  • CORRECTED Meeting Notice and Agenda (PDF-195kb)
  • Draft Workplan Version 2.0 (PDF-67kb)
  • Topics 6 & 7 - Supply and Availability Outline  (PDF-9kb)
  • Topics 8 & 12 - Economic Impacts Outline (PDF-12kb)
  • Topic 9, 10, & 12 - Environmental Impacts Outline (PDF-14kb)
  • Topic 14 - HCICO Outline (PDF-20kb)
  • Topic 15 - Credit Trading Outline (PDF-10kb)
  • Draft Report Chapter 4 - Technology Assessment (PDF-31kb)
  • Overview (PDF-349kb)
  • Panelist Presentation - Cathy Reheis-Boyd - WSPA Compliance Challenge Slides (PDF-241kb)
  • Panelist Presentation - Bob Epstein - E2 Outline (PDF-299kb)
  • Panelist Presentation - Simon Mui - NRDC HCICO Presentation (PDF-1.02MB)
  • Panelist Presentation - Wood Mackenzie on behalf of WSPA - HCICO Presentation (PDF-2.21MB)
  • Summary of second advisory panel meeting (PDF-45kb)
April 26, 2011 The second LCFS Advisory Panel meeting will take place on April 26, 2011.  

During this meeting we will discuss the workplan and whether the approach and sources identified in it are adequate to address the pertinent topics.

The meeting will be held at the following time and location:

DATE:            Tuesday, April 26, 2011
TIME:             9:00 am – 4:00 pm
LOCATION:    Coastal Hearing Room, 2nd Floor
                     Cal/EPA Headquarters Building
                     1001 “I” Street
                     Sacramento, California 95814

The meeting will also be available via teleconference and webinar.  To call in by telephone, see details below:

You may participate by teleconference by dialing 888-946-4303 (for domestic) or 1‑415-228-4977 (for international), give the participant code 3990262, and leader name Mike Waugh.  Please note that if you call internationally, it is a toll call.

If you chose to participate via webinar,
please register.

If prompted, the webinar ID is: 736-074-393. If you choose to participate via gotowebinar’s audio system and not the teleconference call-in number, you will only be able to listen and see the presentations.  You will not be able to participate using a microphone and must use the call in information provided in the meeting notice if you wish to ask a question verbally.  You may also type your questions to us using a chat box that will be available to you during the webinar.  Staff will be using a computer to answer any questions submitted through the webinar dialogue box.  In the event that the webinar fails, please call in to continue participating.


February 16, 2011
The first LCFS Advisory Panel meeting will take place on February 16, 2011.  

During this meeting we will cover the purpose of the Panel, review the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, give an overview of the LCFS, and discuss both the agenda/workplan for the year and one of the required topics for review: advances in full fuel-lifecycle analysis.

The meeting will be held at the following time and location:

DATE:            Wednesday, February 16, 2011
TIME:             9:00 am – 4:00 pm
LOCATION:    Coastal Hearing Room, 2nd Floor
                     Cal/EPA Headquarters Building
                     1001 “I” Street
                     Sacramento, California 95814
 

DOCUMENTS

PRESENTATION HANDOUTS



preload