You are here: ARB Home Low Carbon Fuel Standard Stakeholder Letters in response to LCFS Workshops

Stakeholder Letters in response to LCFS Workshops

This page last reviewed January 11, 2018


This page provides a list of all letters received in response to LCFS workshops. Please send all feedback to LCFSWorkshop@arb.ca.gov.

Please note that these letters, attachments, and associated contact information (e.g. address, phone, email, etc.) become part of the viewable public record. Additionally, this information may become available via Google, Yahoo, and any other search engines.

[+]  Workshop: November 6, 2017

November 6, 2017 Workshop to discuss the development of program amendments
# Received From Date Received
1 PTS Staffing Solutions October 22, 2017
2Renewable Fuels AssociationNovember 16, 2017
3Air Liquide, FirstElement Fuel Inc., American Honda Motor Co, Inc., Mercedes-Benz Research & Development North America, Inc., Shell New Energies, Toyota Motor North America
Attachment: Draft Hydrogen LCFS Infrastructure Pathway Regulatory Provision
November 29, 2017
4Shell Oil Company
Attachment: Draft Hydrogen LCFS Infrastructure Pathway Regulatory Provision
November 29, 2017
5ColturaNovember 27, 2017
6Pico Rivera Innovative Municipal Energy (PRIME)November 30, 2017
7Pioneer Community EnergyNovember 30, 2017
8Red Trail Energy, LLCDecember 4, 2017
9Shell Energy North America (US), L.P. (Shell Energy)December 4, 2017
10Center for Sustainable Energy (CSE)December 4, 2017
11Carbon Sequestration Council (CSC)
Attachment A: Geologic Sequestration of Carbon Dioxide - Underground Injection Control (UIC) Program Class VI Primacy Manual for State Directors
December 4, 2017
12SRECTradeDecember 4, 2017
13Nel Hydrogen (NEL)December 4, 2017
14BP America, Inc.December 4, 2017
15General Motors LLC (GM)December 4, 2017
16ChargePoint, Inc.December 4, 2017
17San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC)December 4, 2017
18California Natural Gas Vehicle Coalition (CNGVC), Coalition for Renewable Natural Gas (CRNG), Bioenergy Association of California (BAC)December 4, 2017
19Western States Petroleum Association (WSPA)December 4, 2017
20Kern Oil & Refining Co. (Kern)December 4, 2017
21NextGen CaliforniaDecember 4, 2017
22Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL)December 4, 2017
23Clean EnergyDecember 4, 2017
24Center for Resource Solutions (CRS)December 4, 2017
25Golden Gate Zero Emission MarineDecember 4, 2017
26Smart EV Charging Group (Electric Motor Werks, Inc., ChargePoint, WattTime, Sonoma Clean Power, MCE Clean Energy, Lancaster Choice Energy, Peninsula Clean Energy, Silicon Valley Clean Energy, American Honda Motor Co. Inc., Volta Charging, Chanje Energy, Inc., EDF Renewable Energy)December 4, 2017
27University of Texas at AustinDecember 5, 2017
28North Dakota Industrial Commission's Oil and Gas Division (NDIC)December 4, 2017
29Occidental Petroleum CoporationDecember 5, 2017
30RPMG Inc.December 5, 2017
31Silicon Valley Clean Energy Authority (SVCE)December 4, 2017
32Global Carbon Capture and Storage Institute, Stanford University, Occidental Petroleum Corporation, California Resources Corporation, Carbon Wrangler, LLC, University of Texas at Austin, EBR Development, LLC, Clean Air Task Force, Center for Climate and Energy Solutions, Natural Resources Defense Council, Shell, Chevron Corporation, White Energy, Conestoga Energy Partners, LLCDecember 4, 2017
33Natural Resources Defense CouncilDecember 4, 2017
34Fulcrum BioEnergy, Inc.December 11, 2017
35Los Angeles Department of Water & PowerDecember 6, 2017
36Northern California Power Agency (NCPA)December 14, 2017
37Western States Petroleum Association (WSPA)December 15, 2017
38California Electric Transportation Coalition (CalETC)December 21, 2017
39Life Cycle AssociatesDecember 22, 2017
40California Hydrogen Business CouncilJanuary 5, 2018
41Western Propane Gas AssociationJanuary 5, 2018
42BonsucroJanuary 9, 2018

[+]  Workshop: September 22, 2017

September 22, 2017 Workshop to discuss proposed amendments to the Low Carbon Fuel Standard regulation
# Received From Date Received
1 PTS Staffing Solutions September 10, 2017
2 Christianson PLLP September 15, 2017
3 United Airlines September 20, 2017
4 DVO, Inc. October 4, 2017
5 Organic Waste Systems, Inc. (OWS) October 5, 2017
6 quasar energy group October 4, 2017
7 DMT Clear Gas Solutions LLC. October 4, 2017
8 Ecostrat Inc. October 4, 2017
9 The Boeing Company October 3, 2017
10 Bioenergy Association of California (BAC) October 5, 2017
11 StormFisher Environmental Ltd October 5, 2017
12 AAT America Inc. October 5, 2017
13 ReCon Associates, LLC October 5, 2017
14 TSS Consultants October 5, 2017
15 Yield Biogas Solutions October 5, 2017
16 SCS Energy October 5, 2017
17 Clean Fuel Partners, LLC October 5, 2017
18 Environmental Energy Capital (EEC) October 5, 2017
19 American Biogas Council (ABC) October 5, 2017
20 Enerkem October 6, 2017
21 PlanET Biogas October 5, 2017
22 BioGas Corp October 6, 2017
23 Beyond Energy, LLC October 6, 2017
24 Green Era Sustainability October 5, 2017
25 White Energy, Inc. October 6, 2017
26 SoCalGas October 6, 2017
27 BioCNG, LLC October 5, 2017
28 Unison Solutions October 6, 2017
29 Regenis October 6, 2017
30 Union of Concerned Scientists October 6, 2017
31 MV Technologies October 5, 2017
32 CH4 Biogas (CH4) October 6, 2017
33 Gas Technology Institute (GTI) October 6, 2017
34 Maas Energy Works, Inc. October 5, 2017
35 Alternative Jet Fuel Producers (AltAir Fuels, Fulcrum BioEnergy, Neste, Red Rock Biofuels, and Velocys) October 6, 2017
36 Flint Hills Resources, LC October 6, 2017
37 Montana Advanced Biofuels, LLC
Attachment: EPA's approval of New Fuel Pathway for Barley
October 6, 2017
38 California Association of Sanitation Agencies (CASA) October 6, 2017
39 Calgren Renewable Fuels (CRF) October 5, 2017
40 California Natural Gas Vehicle Coalition (CNGVC) October 6, 2017
41 Kern Oil & Refining Co. October 6, 2017
42 Trillium Transportation Fuels October 6, 2017
43 Bloom Energy October 6, 2017
44 NextGen California October 6, 2017
45 EVgo October 6, 2017
46 Neste October 6, 2017
47 Smart EV Charging Group (Electric Motor Werks, Inc., ChargePoint, WattTime, Sonoma Clean Power, MCE Clean Energy, Lancaster Choice Energy, Peninsula Clean Energy, Silicon Valley Clean Energy, American Honda Motor Co. Inc., Volta Charging, Chanje Energy, Inc., EDF Renewable Energy) October 6, 2017
48 Iogen Corporation October 6, 2017
49 Newtrient LLC October 5, 2017
50 Pentair Union Engineering North America October 5, 2017
51 EBR Development, LLC October 6, 2017
52 Bulk Handling Systems October 5, 2017
53 RPMG, Inc. October 6, 2017
54 Clean Energy October 6, 2017
55 The Coalition for Renewable Natural Gas (RNG Coalition) October 6, 2017
56 Chevron October 10, 2017
57 Western States Petroleum Assoication (WSPA) October 10, 2017
58 Zero Waste Energy, LLC October 5, 2017
59 RPMG, Inc.
Attachment: EPA Efficient Producer Calculation Models
October 16, 2017
60 UNICA October 17, 2017
61 Las Gallinas Valley Sanitary District (LGVSD) October 6, 2017
62 National Biodiesel Board (NBB) October 19, 2017
63 Global Carbon Capture and Storage Institute, Stanford University, Occidental Petroleum Corporation, California Resources Corporation, White Energy, EBR Development, LLC, Clean Air Task Force, Center for Climate and Energy Solutions, Natural Resources Defense Council, Shell, Chevron Corporation, Conestoga Energy Partners, LLC October 20, 2017
64 Agility Fuel Solutions October 6, 2017
65 California Electric Transportation Coalition (CalETC) October 26, 2017
66 Western Propane Gas Associates (WPGA) October 24, 2017
67 California Biodiesel Alliance (CBA) October 26, 2017
68 Sonoma County Transportation Authority October 27, 2017
69 Christianson PLLP November 3, 2017
70 RPMG, Inc. November 3, 2017
71 Ethanol Industry (Nebraska Ethanol Board, Clean Fuels Development Coalition, Archer Daniels Midland Company, Prairie Horizon Agri Energy, White Energy, Southwest Iowa Renewable Energy, Western Plains Energy, LLC, Golden Grain Energy, LLC, Siouxland Ethanol, LLC, Kansas Ethanol, LLC, Little Sioux Corn Processors, Great Plains Institute) October 31, 2017
72 Renewable Energy Group, Inc. (REG) November 7, 2017
73Menlo SparkNovember 17, 2017
74Iogen CorporationDecember 13, 2017

[+]  Workshop: August 7, 2017

August 7, 2017 Workshop on program amendments to strengthen CI reduction targets, mandatory third party verification, revisions to credit generating provisions, update the lifecycle assessment tool, and solicitation of alternative approaches
# Received From Date Received
1 Imperial Western Products August 7, 2017
2 H2 Renewables
Attachment: On the Catalytic Aspects of Steam-Methane Reforming
August 14, 2017
3 Life Cycle Associates
Attachment: September 18, 2014 Comments on Ethanol Denaturant Blending
August 14, 2017
4 Clean Energy Systems, Inc. August 15, 2017
5 NextGen California August 21, 2017
6 Western States Petroleum Association August 21, 2017
7 Intersect Power August 21, 2017
8 Valero August 31, 2017
9 Energy Independence Now (EIN) September 1, 2017
10 EVgo September 1, 2017
11 ITM Power September 1, 2017
12 California Fuel Cell Partnership (CaFCP) September 1, 2017
13 ICE Futures U.S., Inc. (IFUS) September 4, 2017
14 Nel Hydrogen Inc. September 4, 2017
15 California Biodiesel Alliance (CBA) September 1, 2017
16 Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) September 4, 2017
17 Crimson Renewable Energy, LP September 3, 2017
18 Weaver and Tidwell, L.L.P. September 4, 2017
19 Idemitsu Apollo (IAC) September 5, 2017
20 Bloom Energy September 4, 2017
21 Tesla September 5, 2017
22 Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E) September 5, 2017
23 Bioenergy Association of California (BAC) September 5, 2017
24 American Lung Association September 5, 2017
25 California Natural Gas Vehicle Coalition (CNGVC) September 5, 2017
26 Macpherson Oil Company (MOC) September 5, 2017
27 Smart EV Charging Group (Electric Motor Werks, Inc., ChargePoint, WattTime, Sonoma Clean Power, MCE Clean Energy, Lancaster Choice Energy, Peninsula Clean Energy, Silicon Valley Clean Energy, American Honda Motor Co. Inc.) September 5, 2017
28 Clean Energy Fuels September 5, 2017
29 The Coalition for Renewable Natural Gas (RNG Coalition) September 5, 2017
30 Chevron Products Company September 6, 2017
31 SoCalGas September 5, 2017
32 Western States Petroleum Association September 7, 2017
33 NextGen California September 6, 2017
34 Silicon Valley Clean Energy Authority (SVCE) September 6, 2017
35 RPMG Inc (RPMG) September 7, 2017
36 GlassPoint Solar Inc (GlassPoint) September 8, 2017
37 California Hydrogen Business Council (CHBC) September 1, 2017
38 California Independent Petroleum Association (CIPA) September 8, 2017
39 Brazilian Sugarcane Industry Association (UNICA) September 8, 2017
40 Kern Oil & Refining Co (Kern) September 8, 2017
41 Joint Publicly Owned Utilities (Joint POUs) September 14, 2017
42 Flint Hills Resources (FHR)
Appendices A and B: iLUC Literature Sources - post 2015 CA LCFS Readoption (Appendix A) and Models (Appendix B)
September 19, 2017
43 California Electric Transportation Coalition (CalETC) September 13, 2017

[+]  Working Meeting: April 17, 2017

[+]  Working Meeting: March 17, 2017

March 17, 2017 Working Meeting on potentially including Alternative Jet Fuel in the LCFS
# Received From Date Received
1 Alternative Jet Fuel Producers (Neste, Red Rock Biofuels, AltAir Fuels, Velocys, and Fulcrum BioEnergy) February 28, 2017
2 United Airlines February 24, 2017
3 Airlines for America (A4A) March 16, 2017
4 American Airlines March 16, 2017
5 Chalmers University of Technology, Sweden and University of California, Davis April 10, 2017
6 Western States Petroleum Association (WSPA) April 14, 2017
7 Western Propane Gas Association (WPGA) April 17, 2017
8 Alternative Jet Fuel Producers (Neste, Red Rock Biofuels, AltAir Fuels, Velocys, and Fulcrum BioEnergy) April 27, 2017
9 Airlines for America (A4A) April 28, 2017
10 Renewable Energy Group, Inc. (REG) (same as 5th letter in February 10, 2017 meeting) May 2, 2017
11 Alternative Jet Fuel Producers (Neste, Red Rock Biofuels, AltAir Fuels, Velocys, and Fulcrum BioEnergy)
Exhibit A: Proposed Regulatory Language
June 29, 2017
12 California Bicycle Coalition July 13, 2017
13 Biotechnology Innovation Organization (BIO) July 18, 2017

[+]  Working Meeting: February 10, 2017

February 10, 2017 Working Meeting on Biodiesel and Renewable Diesel
# Received From Date Received
1 EcoEngineers (same as 4th letter in January 31, 2017 meeting) February 28, 2017
2 Pilot Flying J March 10, 2017
3 Western States Petroleum Association (WSPA) March 10, 2017
4 National Biodiesel Board (NBB) and California Biodiesel Alliance (CBA) March 10, 2017
5 Renewable Energy Group, Inc. (REG) (same as 10th letter in March 17, 2017 meeting) May 2, 2017

[+]  Working Meeting: February 7, 2017

[+]  Working Meeting: January 31, 2017

January 31, 2017 Working Meeting on Ethanol
# Received From Date Received
1 POET Biorefining January 31, 2017
2 Raizen Energia S/A February 24, 2017
3 Western States Petroleum Association (WSPA) February 28, 2017
4 EcoEngineers (same as 1st letter in February 10, 2017 meeting) February 28, 2017
5 White Energy, Inc. March 2, 2017
6 Renewable Products Marketing Group (RPMG)
Attachment: Revised Example Form xlsm
March 10, 2017
7 Life Cycle Associates March 10, 2017
8 Conestoga Energy Partners, LLC March 9, 2017
9 Conestoga Energy Partners, LLC June 16, 2017
10 Life Cycle Associates July 12, 2017

[+]  Working Meeting: December 19, 2016

[+]  Working Meeting: December 13, 2016

December 13, 2016 Working Meeting on Refinery Co-Processing
# Received From Date Received
1 BP America, Inc (BP) January 16, 2017
2 Western States Petroleum Association (WSPA) January 16, 2017
3 Safety-Kleen January 19, 2017

[+]  Working Meeting: December 5, 2016

December 5, 2016 Working Meeting on Fossil and Renewable Hydrogen
# Received From Date Received
1 H2 Renewables December 14, 2016
2 Planet Hydrogen December 14, 2016
3 Nel Hydrogen Inc. January 5, 2017
5 H2 Renewables May 11, 2017

[+]  Workshop: October 24, 2016

[+]  Workshop: July 29, 2016

[+]  Workshop: June 2, 2016

June 2, 2016 Workshop
# Received From Date Received
1 Copersucar S.A. June 6, 2016
2 Air Products and Chemicals, Inc. June 15, 2016
3 DuPont Industrial Biosciences June 16, 2016
4 Sierra Energy June 16, 2016
5 EcoEngineers June 16, 2016
6 Brazilian Sugarcane Industry Association (UNICA) June 16, 2016
7 Sonoma Clean Power Authority June 16, 2016
8 First Environment June 16, 2016
9 National Biodiodiesel Board/California Biodiesel Alliance June 16, 2016
10 The Coalition for Renewable Natural Gas June 17, 2016
11 GlassPoint Solar Inc. June 20, 2016
12 California Independent Petroleum Association June 21, 2016
13 Western States Petroleum Association June 22. 2016
14 Christianson & Associates, PLLP June 23, 2016
15 Weaver and Tidwell, L.L.P. June 23, 2016
16 PlanetH2 June 27, 2016
17 Renewable Products Marketing Group June 27, 2016
18 Renewable Fuels Association June 28, 2016
19 AltAir Paramount, LLC June 28, 2016
20 Renewable Energy Group, Inc. June 30, 2016
21 Genscape, Inc. July 5, 2016
22 Clean Energy July 7, 2016
23 California Resources Corporation May 5, 2017

[+]  Workshop: March 8, 2016

March 8, 2016 Workshop
# Received From Date Received
1 International Sustainability & Carbon Certification March 8, 2016
2 Christianson & Associates, PLLP March 18, 2016
3 Los Angeles Department of Water & Power March 18, 2016
4 GHI Energy March 18, 2016
5 Growth Energy March 21, 2016
6 Valero March 21, 2016
7 Renewable Products Marketing Group
March 22, 2016
8 Argus Media March 22, 2016
9 National Biodiesel Board March 22, 2016
10 California Biodiesel Alliance March 22, 2016
11 EcoEngineers March 22, 2016
12 Genscape March 22, 2016
13 Renewable Energy Group, Inc. March 22, 2016
14 Renewable Products Marketing Group March 23, 2016
15 Pacific Ethanol March 23, 2016
16 Western States Petroleum Association March 28, 2016


Archives





preload