Comment Log Display

Here is the comment you selected to display.

Comment 3 for AB179 Joint Meeting with CARB/CTC/HCD (ab179carbctchcd2022) - Non-Reg.

First NameConnie
Last NameBurke
Email Addressclcairns@hotmail.com
AffiliationConcerned Citizen
SubjectRegulations impacting new car purchase out of state
Comment

Hello,

My name is Connie Burke. I have been born and raised in Southern California and am very upset about some recent regulations I learned about that have impacted my family.

My husband and I work extremely hard to afford life here in Southern California as a young millenial family with a small toddler and newborn. With a newborn, we decided my compact car that I have had for 10 years was no longer going to be able to serve our needs as a family of four a we decided to purchase a SUV. I did a tremendous amount of research and found it was more cost effective for us to purchase a new 2022 vehicle than purchase a used vehicle and found a great price on the vehicle we were looking for in Arizona.

Obviously, travelling to Arizona with a newborn and toddler isn't ideal so we went to a local Southern California dealership that had the same vehicle and tried to negotiate a fair price. They wanted over $7000 more than the dealership in Arizona. With that large difference in costs, we decided to move forward on the vehicle in Arizona after carefully reading the DMV website and confirming the vehicle was 50 state certified and had the emissions sticker.

We brought the vehicle home and I then had the surprise of finding out that my brand new vehicle needed to get a smog check before the DMV would issue the registration. I took the vehicle to be smogged, paid almost $50 out of pocket to be told the vehicle was not ready to be smogged. I had a long conversation with the smog tech and then a long conversation with the car dealership who both confirmed, the car is too new to be smogged and needs to be driven. The dealership recommended I wait until I had 1000 miles on the vehicle before completing a smog check. I only drive 3000 miles a year. 

To make this clear, I now have to purposely go out to drive my brand new vehicle to get the miles on it to be able to be ready to be smogged. That is wasting my time, gas (which is extremely costly right now), money and bringing unnecessary emissions to get this vehicle to be at a point where it's ready for a smog check. And I will now have to pay for a second smog test, directly impacting the bottom line on my family finances, again. 

If this exact same vehicle had been sold to me in CA, it wouldn't have to be smogged. It's not like the state isn't getting their money from the sale - I have to pay the difference in the sales tax, have to pay the DMV for the title transfer and registration/license fees.

I can understand the need for a smog if this was a used vehicle coming in from out of state, but this is a brand new vehicle. The state doesn't require a smog check on new vehicles for a few years. I'm hoping I can make you see how illogical it is to reasonable people like me that you requrie a smog check on a brand new, 50 state certified vehicle and how it costs a middle class family like mine precious time and resources.

Please consider changing the regulations.

Best,

Connie


Attachment
Original File Name
Date and Time Comment Was Submitted 2022-10-23 09:36:05

If you have any questions or comments please contact Clerk of the Board at (916) 322-5594.


Board Comments Home