Comment Log Display

Here is the comment you selected to display.

Comment 4 for Greenhouse Gas Heavy Duty Vehicles (SmartWay) (ghghdv08) - 15-1.

First NameJohn
Last NameDodds
Email AddressJDoddsGW@sbcglobal.net
Affiliation
SubjectAdded CO2 does NOT cause warming
Comment
Variable Energy NOT CO2 causes Cooling & Warming.
 
Climate change is natural, not caused by CO2. Added CO2 does NOT
cause added warming. Added CO2 causes added excess CO2 in the air,
just like Oxygen and Nitrogen, the other chemicals in the natural
plant, animal food chain.
The greenhouse effect (GHE) only works when there is sufficient
energy of the appropriate frequency, AND sufficient GHGs such as
CO2 and water vapor.
In the case of the Earth, the energy is limited by what comes in
and goes out. 
In the air there is excess CO2 because whenever the temperature
cools down some of the CO2 that was being used to transport energy
to space (& to produce the GHE), is no longer needed at the cooler
temperatures and with the smaller amounts of transportable energy.
Thus there is always, and MUST BE,  excess CO2 in the air,
available to handle the daily global warming when the sun comes up.
Now at the average temperature of 16C, there is at least more than
40% excess CO2,  ( or over 112ppm from the peak needed to transport
energy at the 1922 world record 58C), plus the 107+ppm that man has
added. There is at least 219ppm  (out of 387) of CO2 EXCESS in the
air. Also the idea that CO2 "traps" energy is absurd. What has
happened to the energy trapped for the last 4.5 billion years? CO2
catches & releases energy  in microseconds as it transports the
energy to space (& in so doing causes the Greenhouse warming
effect).
Therefore the amount of energy being transported out, not the CO2,
dictates the amount of greenhouse effect. The computer models and
IPCC conclusion that more added CO2 results in more added
greenhouse effect is factually INCORRECT. More CO2 just adds more
CO2 to the excess in the air. (Think Dinosaurs & lush forests when
CO2 was 2000ppm)
Since by computer model and IPCC assumptions, the solar
insolation/sunlight is  (erroneously) the sole source of energy
coming in and going out (gravity causes tides and friction in the
ocean and in the liquid Earth core), then  any increase of the GHE
is limited by an increase in the energy in. which according to
scientific measurements and IPCC has not changed significantly
since about 1960. 
This means several things. First since global warming has
increased from 1970 through 1998, then the computer models are not
correct, and second, there MUST be an additional source of kinetic
energy coming into the Earth in addition to solar insolation, that
is larger than solar insolation.
Finally, since there is excess CO2 in the air, then removing CO2
by Cap & Trade etc. will only remove the excess CO2. It will not
result in lower temperatures. 
 
Climate change is natural. It is caused by the Earth's
eccentricity which is mostly caused by the gravity from the planets
Jupiter and Saturn. John Dodds Wobble Theory of Global Warming  Fig
12d (www.scribd.com) identifies that GRAVITY from the planets and
the sun, correlates with the measured global temperatures,  both 
for the most recent 60 year cycles 1880,1940, 1998, & the future
cooling to 2028 and warming to 2058 and for thousands of years
before (picture included below) . Specifically, there is a near 60
year planetary gravity resonance cycle of Jupiter and Saturn that
peaks at the same time as the  temperature and causes the observed
30 year cooling then 30 year warming cycle. This  Jupiter &
Saturn's gravity cycle also causes the Earth's and Venus's
eccentricity. When the Earth is closest to the Jupiter/Saturn
resonance point of greatest attraction then it is also at its
greatest distance to the Sun (most eccentric), or aphelion. BUT six
months earlier or later Earth is also near its perihelion or
closest point to the sun.  At all other times the total energy to
Earth is lower. Thus within a six month period the forces of
gravity to Earth are maximized from both Jupiter/Saturn and the
sun, AND, the solar insolation is maximized , AND the Earth's
potential energy to both the Sun & Jupiter is minimized, all of
which result in  a maximum of the kinetic energy in the Earth or a
temperature peak.  All natural.
 
The IPCC approach to reducing CO2 is scientifically unsound., and
will lead to major expenditures and  reductions of available
energy.with no impact on the temperature. Man can NOT control
gravity and the planets, and so can not control global cooling and
warming. Mark Twain said everyone complains about the weather (&
climate) but noone does anything about it. That's because Mother
Nature is in control of it.
 
All CARB regulations relating to CO2 and Warming are
scientifically NOT justifiable.
YOu are wasting taxpayer money.
Stop .

Attachment www.arb.ca.gov/lists/ghghdv08/203-ptti_temp_1400-2070.jpg
Original File NamePTTI Temp 1400-2070.jpg
Date and Time Comment Was Submitted 2009-09-24 20:09:40

If you have any questions or comments please contact Clerk of the Board at (916) 322-5594.


Board Comments Home