Comment Log Display

Here is the comment you selected to display.

Comment 5 for In-Use Locomotive Regulation (locomotive22) - 45 Day.

First NameJoseph
Last NameDenton
Email Addressjoeddenton@yahoo.com
AffiliationSacramento Resident
SubjectSupport for the Proposed Regulation
Comment

I strongly support the Proposed Regulation.

My family and I reside within Sacramento city limits, on the eastern boundary of the Land Park neighborhood along the railroad right of way immediately south of the intersection of 21st Street and Freeport Boulevard. 

There is a railroad siding adjacent to our home on the other side of the sound wall.  Both Union Pacific and BNSF will often use this siding to stage locomotives engines and cars while they wait for additional locomotives to be brought from the Roseville Railyard.  Sometimes this staging can last anywhere from 24-72 hours in duration.  Our concern is that they consistently leave the locomotive engines idling for the entire duration of staging. This is a very concerning and hazardous practice by the rail operators and presents a significant health risk to my family and other families residing along the railroad right-of-way. It is especially concerning because it is unnecessary. Auxiliary Power Units should be used to maintain brake functionality during these periods. Alternatively, if this staging is truly such a frequent requirement, the rail operators should be required to install shore power to satisfy the power requirements needed for maintaining functionality to the brake system.

I fully support the proposed regulation, specifically the limitation of 30 minutes for locomotive engine idling, coupled with the requirement to report each individual occurrence where rail operators claim an exemption and idle engines in excess of 30 minutes.  Furthermore, I encourage CARB to consider the additional measure of even further scrutiny of these exercised exceptions to the idling limitations when the idling occurs within close proximity to residential properties.  A rail operator claiming they need to maintain brake system functionality and idling a locomotive engine for 72 hours straight within 100 feet of my house may technically satisfy the federal regulations but it does not mitigate the health risks imposed on my family.

Thank you

Joseph Denton


Attachment www.arb.ca.gov/lists/com-attach/app-zip/5-locomotive22-UTdXPgR3BQkAdlQh.zip
Original File Namefor public comment.zip
Date and Time Comment Was Submitted 2022-10-29 10:17:53

If you have any questions or comments please contact Clerk of the Board at (916) 322-5594.


Board Comments Home