Comment Log Display

Comment Log Display

Below is the comment you selected to display.
Comment 24 for 2022 Scoping Plan Update – Initial Air Quality & Health Impacts and Economic Analyses Results Workshop (sp22-econ-health-ws) - 1st Workshop.


First Name: William
Last Name: Murphy
Email Address: wcmurphy19@yahoo.com
Affiliation: Retired

Subject: Vital wins on methane/HFCs are MISSING from the Scoping Plan Update!
Comment:
The current version of the 2022 Scoping Plan is seriously
deficient, if we hope to beat or even slow the emerging climate
crisis.

SHORT LIVED CLIMATE POLLUTANTS LIKE METHANE AND HYDROFLOUROCARBONS
ARE GETTING SHORT SHRIFT, AND ARE NEARLY OMITTIED FROM THE PLAN! 
WHAT IS THERE IS WEAK...

Even though CARB uses a 20-year global warming potential (GWP_
which clearly shows SLCPs causing over 50% of California's
greenhouse forcing, the consultants are using the older 100-year
GWP forcing.  The latter data-choice has the unfortunate effect of
trivializing what are actually our fastest-acting climate solutions
in methane and refrigeration chemicals!

Though it is true we need to work hard on reducing CO2, available
CO2 reductions from transportation, power and buildings sectors ARE
NOT SUFFICIENT.  

We also have to work equally hard on SLCPs, to buy us time for the
slower-acting CO2 reductions to take effect. 

Are the Board and staff or the E3 consultants prone to an
institutional blind spot?  The answer would appear to be 'yes.' 
This is our one chance to catch this critical omission and add
vigor by getting the attached SLCPs-reduction playbook into the
Plan in a big way.

The current Scoping Plan version is not capable of generating a
successful outcome as defined in our state's high level goals. 

Kindly take a very, very careful look at the uploaded 7/9/21 letter
of concrete suggestions from Clean Air Task Force, Climate Reality
California Coalition, Institute for Governance and Sustainable
Development and Environmental Investigation Agency.   

Attachment: www.arb.ca.gov/lists/com-attach/29-sp22-econ-health-ws-AjAGMAY1BWcGcwZl.pdf

Original File Name: 2021scopingplancomments.pdf

Date and Time Comment Was Submitted: 2022-05-03 09:19:46



If you have any questions or comments please contact Office of the Ombudsman at (916) 327-1266.


Board Comments Home

preload